Macclesfield: Code of conduct rule of 'not bringing the council into disrepute’ worries councillor

By Belinda Ryan - Local Democracy Reporter

5th Aug 2022 | Local News

Cllr Marren in a photoshoot to highlight work that the council should do. (Image - Cheshire East Council)
Cllr Marren in a photoshoot to highlight work that the council should do. (Image - Cheshire East Council)

Cheshire East could prevent councillors from working in the best interests of Macclesfield residents if it passes the new revised members code of conduct as it stands, a councillor believes.

Cllr David Marren (Shavington, Ind) told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) that the rule of 'not bringing the council into disrepute' could be interpreted as preventing councillors from criticising the council because that criticism may damage the council's reputation.

"The council sometimes needs to be publicly criticised and criticised in the press, and my experience is that it is necessary to do that before it will do the right thing," he said.

"I've been pictured in the press with grass up to my neck on council-owned land that the council had denied owning, despite being told by me that it did. [See above]

Cllr Marren is a long-serving councillor, first elected in May 2011. (Image - Cheshire East Council)

"I've been quoted criticising the council for repeated Traveller incursions on an open space that they had years to resolve but didn't.

"Criticising the council publicly appears to be a code of conduct breach because that criticism could damage the council's reputation. That is not right and not acceptable and should not be accepted by any councillor who says they put residents first."

Cllr Marren said he has contacted the LDRS about his concerns because he had been 'cut off' during his speech at the audit and governance committee meeting last week because of time constraints.

He listed a number of other concerns about the code and the complaints process, which is due to be considered by full council at a future meeting.

Macclesfield: Do you think this code of conduct rule could prevent councillors from criticising the council? (Image - Cheshire East Council)

One is that councillors are gagged from talking about any complaints made against them, which, he believes,  'restricts their ability to gather supporting evidence'.

The Shavington councillor said the code's insistence on the 'accused' having to stay silent and keep things confidential is coercive and would help any bullies who might manipulate it by making exaggerated complaints.

"Cheshire East Council has been troubled by accusations of bullying in the past so it is really important to get this replacement code of conduct right," said Cllr Marren.

"Code of conduct investigations should be as open and fair and under as much public gaze as any investigation under the judicial system.

"Those under investigation should be free to speak about the investigation. The hearing panel should be able to quiz witnesses, there should be an appeal option and, where officers complain about councillors, it shouldn't be colleague officers who investigate but someone very clearly independent.

Cheshire East Council collect your council tax, organise bin collection, road maintenance, parks and more. They also own Macclesfield buildings Macclesfield Library and Macclesfield Town Hall. (Image - Alexander Greensmith / Macclesfield Nub News)

"And, most of all, councillors should not be afraid to criticise the council – but that will happen if councillors can be subject to a complaint that they have brought the council into disrepute by their public criticism."

Cllr Marren's comments follows a discussion on the code of conduct earlier this week, which was influenced by that infamous Handforth Parish Council meeting.

Please click here to read that story.

Got a business to promote in Macclesfield? Advertise it for FREE on our Local List.

Macclesfield: Have you signed up for our FREE Friday weekly newsletter? It contains each week's top five Macclesfield news stories, and one EXCLUSIVE article?

1400 of you have signed up already. Simply enter your email address on this link.

Free from pop-up ads, or unwanted surveys, Macclesfield Nub News is a quality online newspaper for Macclesfield and the surrounding area.

You can find us on Facebook and Twitter.


Related Articles

David Brown, Macclesfield lad Vincent Morrison (with a photo of his later brother Max) and Crewe resident Stephen Benson at the Thiepval Memorial. (Image - Stephen Benson)
Local News

Over £4000 raised in memory of history-loving Macclesfield teenager

Helsby photographer Duncan Cowley has kindly shared these amazing photos from Macclesfield's Rewind North Festival. Can you see yourself? (Image - Duncan Cowley)
Local News

Macclesfield: All the best pics from Rewind North Festival on Saturday August 6

Nub News Logo

Sign-up to the Macclesfield Nub News weekly newsletter

Subscribe now for weekly updates of local news and sport from your town. Plus what's on near where you live - and local homes for sale. All delivered straight to your in-box, every Friday.

We won't pass your details on to anyone else. By clicking the sign-up button you agree to our Privacy Policy.