Macclesfield taxpayers: Claims signing carbon zero pledge 'could cost' Cheshire East Council £5bn

By Alex Greensmith

25th Oct 2021 | Local News

The borough council which includes Macclesfield has voted to back a nationwide pledge, despite it costing taxpayers billions.

Cheshire East Council has voted to back the UK100 pledge despite claims from one councillor it would cost £5 billion to achieve the carbon zero aims across the borough by 2045.

The motion, proposed by Knutsford councillor Quentin Abel was that Cheshire East makes the UK100 pledge and asks the relevant committee to determine whether the council should join the UK100 Network.

Following some opposition from councillors it was carried with 40 votes in favour, 10 against and 19 abstaining.

Cllr Abel told the full council: "This is the most pressing and important issue that we face as mankind and as a planet.

"This proposal builds on what we have already agreed to do and what we are successfully achieving in Cheshire East."

He said the UK100 pledge 'unleashes the power of our industries and our businesses to move further, and to take direct action'.

"I speak as the owner of a small business [in Manchester] who has indeed done this.

"Often during the week, we are actually net zero and we are achieving that and, when we have excess energy, we give it to Manchester," he said.

Cllr Tony Dean said: "I support this motion in both of its parts, as I believe it will give us even more impetus to carry out the climate change mitigation actions that we've already agreed in this council."

But Wilmslow West and Chorley councillor Mark Goldsmith told the meeting: "I won't commit Cheshire East to a wild promise, costing billions, based on a flimsy-three page motion at the end of the council meeting."

He said: "Cheshire East has already made a commitment that its own activities will be carbon zero by 2025 and we are well on the way to making this happen.

"However this motion says Cheshire East will ensure all its residents and businesses will also be carbon zero by 2045.

"However, just removing all the borough's gas boilers alone will cost around £1bn and these only account for about 20 per cent of our collective emissions, so this pledge will cost £5bn or more to achieve.

"So on what basis is Cheshire East being asked to fund this £5bn investment? Well, there's almost none whatsoever.

"Promising the earth with no way of knowing how we will achieve it, seriously undermines the council's credibility.

"Our word is our bond. We recklessly gamble with our reputation by making such a big, big promise on such flimsy and inadequate plans."

He said the money spent on a £40,000 management report for this could be better used to pay for social workers.

Two Macclesfield's Cheshire East councillors had further comment.

Cllr Nick Mannion, Chair of the Economy and Growth Committee, said "There is a stark contrast between some Conservatives who see climate change as an excuse to demand extra resources for their wards and Labour councillors who have supported the Council in adopting a Carbon Action Plan setting out in detail how Cheshire East Council will become carbon neutral by 2025 - one of the most ambitious targets in the country. Put bluntly - the Conservatives want to prune and cut down trees, while Labour want to plant thousands more trees to sequester carbon out of the atmosphere."

Cllr James Barber, member for Broken Cross and Upton, said "Younger trees absorb more carbon than mature older trees. So it is important to both maintain the trees we have and also to plant new trees.

"The Conservatives did neither when they were in control of Cheshire East Council. Under the new Labour-Independent administration, Cheshire East Council has a tree policy and last year planted over 15,000 trees."

The UK100 pledge includes making Cheshire East's services and premises emit no carbon emissions.

Cheshire East HQ is on Westfields, Middlewich Rd, Sandbach, 17 miles from Macclesfield.

Macclesfield: Have you signed up for our Friday weekly newsletter containing each week's top 10 Macclesfield news stories, and one FREE exclusive article?

790 of you have signed up already. Simply enter your email address into the shaded box below.

Free from pop-up ads, or unwanted surveys, Macclesfield Nub News is a quality online newspaper which produces 25-30 stories a week for our town.

Please consider following us on Twitter and Facebook.

     

New macclesfield Jobs Section Launched!!
Vacancies updated hourly!!
Click here: macclesfield jobs

Share:

Related Articles

The good cause was established in 2020, and ran from Bethel Baptist Church, Calamine Street, Macclesfield SK11 7HU. (image - Macclesfield Nub News)
Local News

Macclesfield Children and Baby Library launches Xmas presents appeal

Click the red link on this article to donate. (Image - Kickstarter)
Local News

Crowdfunder for new Macclesfield music festival launched

Sign-Up for our FREE Newsletter

We want to provide macclesfield with more and more clickbait-free local news.
To do that, we need a loyal newsletter following.
Help us survive and sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter.

Already subscribed? Thank you. Just press X or click here.
We won't pass your details on to anyone else.
By clicking the Subscribe button you agree to our Privacy Policy.